Negligent Security Settlements: 2026 Data
Published negligent security settlements and verdicts nationwide range from $187,000 for a nightclub assault1 to $177 million for a sexual assault by a hotel security guard.2 The largest results in our dataset involve wrongful death, paralysis, or traumatic brain injury.
We compiled 16 reported cases from news coverage, verdict reporting services, and published case results. The tables group the cases by property type and show whether each case ended in a settlement or a jury verdict.
Key Takeaways
- The highest reported outcome in our review was a $177 million jury verdict.2
- Apartment complexes produced 6 of the 16 cases we reviewed, including a $31 million settlement for a 3-year-old shot in Georgia.3
- Seven of the 16 cases ended in settlements, and nine ended in jury verdicts that defendants could challenge on appeal.
- Nine of the 16 results reached $10 million or more.
Settlement Value vs. Trial Value
A settlement is a negotiated agreement. Once both sides sign, the amount becomes final. A jury verdict reflects the amount jurors award at trial, but the defendant can ask the trial court or an appellate court to reduce or overturn it.
The amount a defendant pays can also differ from the headline verdict when the jury splits fault among several defendants. For example, in 2026, a Clark County jury awarded $56.5 million to a man who suffered traumatic brain injuries after an assault at Chayo, a Las Vegas restaurant, in 2021. Caesars Entertainment, one of several defendants, was set to pay more than $28 million of that total.4
The tables below list the reported verdict amount, which may differ from the amount the injured person collects.
Apartment and Residential Property Cases
Apartment cases made up the largest group in our review. Five of the six involved shootings, and four ended in settlements. The following table lists each case from largest to smallest.
| Case | Year Reported | Outcome | Amount | Injury |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apartment complex, Escambia County, Florida5 | 2025 | Jury verdict | $50 million | Gunshot injuries in an attempted murder |
| Arborside Apartments, DeKalb County, Georgia3 | 2026 | Settlement | $31 million | Catastrophic injury to a 3-year-old shot on the property |
| Apartment complex with a history of violent crime6 | Not reported | Settlement | $28.9 million | Quadriplegia from a shooting |
| Apartment complex, Florida7 | 2026 | Settlement | $6 million | Gunshot injuries to a resident |
| The Avenues Apartments, Jacksonville, Florida8 | 2025 | Jury verdict | $3.9 million | Death of a 16-year-old shot in the parking lot |
| Apartment complex9 | 2026 | Settlement | $1 million | Death of a food delivery driver |
Key Insights
Recommended reading: Texas Court Reverses $3.5 Million Apartment Shooting Judgment
Hotel and Motel Cases
Hotel cases produced the largest verdicts in our review. Three of the four ended in jury verdicts, and two involved deaths. The following table lists the reported outcomes for each hotel and motel case.
| Case | Year Reported | Outcome | Amount | Injury |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hyatt Regency, St. Louis, Missouri2 | 2025 | Jury verdict, affirmed on appeal | $177 million | Sexual assault by a hotel security guard |
| Sheraton Grand, Chicago, Illinois10 | 2026 | Jury verdict | $27 million | Injuries to two brothers in a room invasion |
| Motel6 | Not reported | Jury verdict | $12 million | Death of a young woman |
| The Sands Hotel, Riviera Beach, Florida11 | 2026 | Settlement | $5.5 million | Death of a man shot outside a bar on the property |
Key Insights
Retail, Parking Lot, and Gas Station Cases
All four retail cases in our review involved shootings in parking lots, stores, or gas stations. Three ended in jury verdicts. The following table lists each result.
| Case | Year Reported | Outcome | Amount | Injury |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shopping center parking lot6 | Not reported | Jury verdict | $102.7 million | Ventilator-dependent quadriplegia from a shooting |
| Lowe’s parking lot, Portland, Oregon12 | 2024 | Jury verdict | $21.25 million | Death of a man shot by a security guard |
| Convenience store, Kansas City, Missouri13 | 2026 | Settlement | $2 million | Brain injury and cardiac arrest from a gunshot |
| Gas station, Atlanta, Georgia14 | 2017 | Jury verdict | $1.7 million | Gunshot injuries |
Key Insights
Bar, Nightclub, and Restaurant Cases
Our review includes two assault cases at hospitality venues, and the following table compares them.
| Case | Year Reported | Outcome | Amount | Injury |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Restaurant at the Linq Promenade, Las Vegas, Nevada4 | 2026 | Jury verdict | $56.5 million | Traumatic brain injury from a beating |
| Nightclub, New York1 | Not reported | Settlement | $187,500 | Facial wound from a bouncer’s attack |
Key Insights
- The Las Vegas lawsuit alleged that nearby security employees did nothing to stop the attack, and the jury assigned no fault to the injured man.4
- The New York case settled for $187,500 before jury selection, nearly exhausting the available insurance.
Further Reading
- Texas House Bill Sponsored by Big Insurance Would Cap Damages
- TX House Cmte. to Hear Insurance Lobby’s Tort-Reform Bill
- I’ve Been Served With a Texas Subpoena, Am I in Trouble?
To request a PDF copy of this report, reach out through the contact page.
Sources
(14)
- Raphaelson & Levine: $187K Negligent Nightclub Security
- PR Newswire: Missouri Court of Appeals Upholds $177 Million Jury Award in Landmark Case Against Hyatt Corporation
- The Haggard Law Firm: $31 Million Negligent Security Settlement for Child Shot at Georgia Apartment Complex
- Las Vegas Review-Journal: Man Attacked at Strip Restaurant Awarded $56.5M by Clark County Jury
- WEAR: Escambia County Shooting Victim Awarded $50 Million for 2020 Attempted Murder Case
- The Haggard Law Firm: Negligent Security Notable Case Results
- The Haggard Law Firm: $6 Million Settlement in Florida Negligent Security Case
- The Haggard Law Firm: $3.9 Million Judgment by Duval County Jury in Negligent Security Case
- The Haggard Law Firm: $1 Million Negligent Security Settlement for Family of Food Delivery Driver Killed at Apartment Complex
- Hoodline: Jury Hits Sheraton With $27 Million Over Room Invasion
- The Haggard Law Firm: $5.5 Million Recovery for Son of Man Killed at Riviera Beach Hotel Property
- Exlitem: $21.25M Verdict for Wrongful Death in Lowe's Parking Lot Shooting by Security Guard
- Missouri Lawyers Media: Gunshot Victim Settles With Convenience Store, Employees for $2M
- Rafi Law Firm: $1.7 Million Jury Verdict in Fulton County