Free consultation · No fee unless you win · Hablamos Español 1211 W 6th St, Suite 600-122, Austin, TX · (512) 473-6449

‹ All Posts

Texas Court Reverses $3.5 Million Apartment Shooting Judgment

Premises & Apartment Injuries

Texas Court Reverses $3.5 Million Apartment Shooting Judgment

 An apartment shooting in Houston resulted in a $3.5 million judgment against an apartment complex and its management company. On September 22, 2026, however, the Fourteenth Court of Appeals reversed that judgment and ordered a new trial.

The decision in Gatesco, Inc. and APTMC, LLC d/b/a Magnolia Cove Apartments v. Ardon provides an important look at how Texas courts handle negligent-security cases—and why an apartment complex can potentially bear responsibility for a crime even though someone else intentionally committed it.

What Happened at Magnolia Cove Apartments?

Melvin Bonilla lived at Magnolia Cove Apartments in Houston with his wife and daughter. At approximately 10:00 p.m. on November 8, 2016, Bonilla was outside with his brother when four men drove through an open gate into the apartment parking lot. Two men exited the vehicle and approached the brothers in an apparent robbery.

Bonilla’s brother escaped. Bonilla was shot and killed. His widow subsequently brought wrongful-death and survival claims against Magnolia Cove Apartments and Gatesco, the apartment manager. Among other allegations, she contended that the defendants failed to provide adequate security against foreseeable criminal activity.

A jury ultimately found both defendants negligent. It assigned 35% responsibility to Magnolia Cove and 65% to Gatesco. The trial court entered a $3.5 million judgment. But there was a significant problem with the jury charge.

Why Did the Court of Appeals Reverse the $3.5 Million Judgment?

Texas law allows juries in many tort cases to allocate responsibility among defendants and certain other people who contributed to an injury—including properly designated “responsible third parties.”

Before trial, the apartment defendants had designated several alleged participants in the robbery as responsible third parties. The defendants therefore asked the trial judge to allow the jury to consider whether two identified alleged assailants, Philip Battles and Ferrell Dardar, also bore responsibility for Bonilla’s death.

The trial court refused. The Fourteenth Court of Appeals concluded that was reversible error.

The appellate court pointed to evidence including eyewitness identifications contained in police investigative records, testimony concerning cellphone-location evidence, and testimony regarding the police investigation. The court concluded there was more than a scintilla of evidence from which a reasonable jury could determine that Battles and Dardar participated in the assault. That was enough to require their inclusion in the proportionate-responsibility question. The court therefore reversed the judgment and sent the case back for a new trial.

A property owner ordinarily isn’t automatically responsible simply because a crime occurs on its property. Texas courts examine whether the risk of criminal conduct was sufficiently foreseeable and unreasonable to create a duty to take reasonable precautions.

But the fact that a criminal intentionally caused an injury does not necessarily eliminate a property owner’s potential responsibility.Those can be separate questions: What responsibility belongs to the person who committed the crime, and did the property owner independently fail to take reasonable precautions against a foreseeable risk?

The Magnolia Cove decision illustrates why both questions can matter at trial.

Injured at an Austin Apartment Complex?

Serious apartment injury cases can involve shootings and assaults, but also dangerous stairs, inadequate lighting, broken gates, fires, swimming pools, balconies and other unsafe property conditions.

Determining whether an apartment owner may be legally responsible usually requires much more than looking at the accident itself. An experienced apartment injury lawyer may investigate prior crimes or incidents, maintenance records, resident complaints, security measures, surveillance footage, police records, inspections and what property management knew before someone was injured.

If you or a family member suffered a serious injury at an apartment complex in Austin or Central Texas, consider speaking with a qualified Austin-area apartment injury lawyer who can evaluate the particular facts and applicable Texas law.

Ardalan Injury Law represents people seriously injured at apartment complexes and other properties throughout the Austin area. Contact our office for a consultation about your case.