Free consultation · No fee unless you win · Hablamos Español 1211 W 6th St, Suite 600-122, Austin, TX · (512) 473-6449

‹ All Posts

Why Did the Judge Lower Johnny Depp’s $15M Award After Trial?

Texas Law & Courts

Why Did the Judge Lower Johnny Depp's $15M Award After Trial?

In his case against Amber Heard, Johnny Depp argued that he was entitled to compensatory damages as well as punitive damages. The compensatory damages are for economic damages that can be ascertained from his lost profits, reputational damages, and other actual damages that were suffered by Johnny Depp. On the other hand, punitive damages are awarded solely as punishment for bad behavior, and are not related to any actual damages suffered by Depp; they are meant to deter or punish bad actors. 

At the end of the trial, the jury awarded:

$10 million to Johnny Depp for compensation damages for Amber Heard’s defamatory statements.

$5 million to Johnny Depp as punitive damages because Amber Heard’s statements were made with malice.

$2 million to Amber Heard for compensation damages for Johnny Depp’s defamatory statements.

$0 to Amber Heard as punitive damages.

Under Virginia law, there is no cap on compensatory or actual damages but there is a cap on punitive damages. Virginia statute § 8.01-38.1 places a cap of $350,000.00 on all punitive damages. As soon as the verdict was read awarding Johnny Depp $5 million, the judge revised the award down to the maximum, which is $350k. This is a somewhat controversial practice and not all states have caps on punitive damages. Texas has a $1 million on some punitive damages (which are called exemplary damages).  

Also, because Amber Heard prevailed on her counter claim with a $2 million dollar compensatory damages award, her liability will be offset. Johnny Depp’s initial $15 million was reduced to $10,350,000 by the judge and to a further $8,350,000 by virtue of Amber Heard prevailing on her counterclaim. If you have any questions about defamation, punitive damages or trials, feel free to reach out to the Ardalan Law Firm PLLC for a free consultation.