Free consultation · No fee unless you win · Hablamos Español 1211 W 6th St, Suite 600-122, Austin, TX · (512) 473-6449

‹ All Posts

Ardalan Injury Law Defeats Summary Judgment Against Austin Booting Company in Violent Attack Case

Firm News

Case update graphic: summary judgment denied in an Austin booting company case

You’ve probably seen a steel tire boot clamped on someone’s car before. Most people don’t expect parking enforcement personnel to swing that boot at their head. And yet, for one of our clients, that is what happened. The booting company, Central Parking Enforcement (CPE), recently asked the court to dismiss the claims. Ardalan Injury Law defeated summary judgment and is proceeding to trial.

What Happened?

On April 6, 2024, our client’s girlfriend was working as a delivery driver. Gas station staff told her she couldn’t park in their lot unless she paid $50 and directed her to the Life Storage lot next door. Within a minute of her stepping away from her car, a CPE operator booted it.

Our client came to help and asked to speak with a manager. CPE then sent a second operator, Roilan Zapata. According to our client’s testimony, Zapata raised the boot above his head with his arms spread wide and walked toward our client. He brought the boot down and struck the back of our client’s head. He then swung it again and hit his own CPE coworker in the chest.

CPE’s Defense: Zapata Was a Contractor

CPE did not dispute that the boot hit our client. Instead, it moved for summary judgment, arguing that Zapata was an “independent contractor” acting on his own and that the company could not be held responsible for what he did. CPE made this argument even though it had dispatched Zapata to the lot and supplied the equipment he used.

To defeat summary judgment, the Plaintiff had to show the court that real factual disputes existed for a jury to decide. Ardalan Injury Law built that record through depositions of CPE’s own operators.

CPE controlled the work

Zapata testified that CPE paid him $22 an hour, set a mandatory 6 p.m. to 3 a.m. schedule, assigned his supervisor, and supplied his boots, receipt books, and card readers. A CPE supervisor called him while he was already on the clock and sent him to the Life Storage lot. Under Texas law, a contract that calls someone an independent contractor does not end the question. Courts look at who controlled the details of the work, and the evidence showed that CPE did.

CPE’s training pushed operators toward confrontation

CPE told the court its operators were trained in de-escalation, but its own operators described something different. Both testified that if someone removed a booted tire, CPE’s protocol was to escalate by booting another tire. CPE admitted its operational guidance came mostly by word of mouth. When asked why he didn’t go back to his car, Zapata said he was “trying to immobilize the vehicle again.”

We argued that a jury could find CPE’s training steered its operator into the confrontation rather than away from it. We also pointed out that Texas courts can hold an employer responsible for an employee’s use of force when it is closely tied to the job the employer sent him to do. Finally, we argued that jurors do not need an expert to understand that sending workers with heavy metal boots into foreseeable confrontations calls for clear safety training.

The Result

The court denied CPE’s motion for summary judgment. CPE can’t end the case before trial on the theory that Zapata was a contractor. A Travis County jury will now decide CPE’s liability, including our claims for negligent training and gross negligence.

Past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Hurt by a Business’s Employee in Austin?

Companies often try to avoid responsibility by calling their workers “contractors.” Ardalan Injury Law knows how to show who was actually in control. If you were injured by a security guard, bouncer, tow operator, or booting company in Austin, contact Ardalan Injury Law for a free consultation.

Schedule a Free Consultation With Ard Ardalan | Call: (512) 473-6449