Free consultation · No fee unless you win · Hablamos Español 1211 W 6th St, Suite 600-122, Austin, TX · (512) 473-6449

‹ All Posts

TX House Cmte. to Hear Insurance Lobby’s Tort-Reform Bill

Truck & Commercial Accidents

TX House Cmte. to Hear Insurance Lobby's Tort-Reform Bill

Texas House Bill 4806: 

Read the bill Here

Stream the hearing Here; hearing officially starts at 7:00 am CST on 5/6/2025

If you cannot make it to the hearing to testify, submit a written comment Here.  

Texas House Bill 4806, set for hearing before the House Judiciary & Civil Jurisprudence Committee, proposes sweeping changes to how damages are awarded in civil lawsuits. This bill has sparked significant concern among consumer and legal advocates, particularly because it threatens to severely limit access to justice for injury victims and their families.

What HB 4806 Proposes

At its core, HB 4806 introduces caps and restrictions on economic and noneconomic damages in personal injury and wrongful death cases. It fundamentally alters the power of Texas juries and is a blatant invasion of Texans’ Seventh Amendment Rights. These changes would significantly shift the burden of proof and reduce the compensation available to victims, even in clear cases of negligence or harm.

Limits on Medical Expense Recovery

HB 4806 rewrites how plaintiffs can recover healthcare expenses. Under the new standard:

  • Plaintiffs would only be allowed to recover the lesser of what was actually paid by third-party insurers, amounts paid directly (without rebates or kickbacks), or 150% of median reimbursements as listed in the Texas All-Payor Claims Database.
  • If an injured person didn’t use available insurance, it could be considered a failure to mitigate damages, limiting their recovery.
  • Invoices must meet strict formatting standards, and undocumented services (like alternative treatments) wouldn’t be recoverable. 

Strict Affidavit Rules Under Section 18.001

Previously, affidavits from healthcare providers could be used to prove the reasonableness and necessity of medical bills. This was essentially to make personal injury trials more efficient and to allow doctors to testify via affidavit. HB 4806 changes that:

  • If a defense attorney serves a notice to challenge these claims, the affidavits lose evidentiary weight and only serve to authenticate records—not to prove the cost or necessity of care.
  • Additionally, the affidavit cannot be used to prove that the defendant’s actions caused the injury. 

New Caps on Noneconomic Damages

The bill proposes formulas and maximums for noneconomic damages like pain and suffering or emotional anguish:

  • For physical pain: the lesser of three times medical costs or $100,000 per year of expected life.
  • Emotional injuries alone: capped at $1 million in a death action, with MUCH lower caps for cases involving non-fatal bodily harm.
  • Noneconomic damages must meet rigid definitions and be based on clear, “objectively verifiable” evidence. 

Barriers to Provider Testimony and Discovery

HB 4806 prevents plaintiffs from calling treating providers to testify about billing or treatment necessity unless special conditions are met. If providers submit affidavits stating they won’t testify, their charges cannot be explored through discovery unless a court grants special permission.

Why It Matters

Supporters claim HB 4806 would curb inflated medical billing and reduce litigation abuse. However, opponents argue it unfairly favors insurers and corporate defendants at the expense of injured Texans. The bill would disproportionately impact low-income plaintiffs, those relying on letters of protection, and individuals without comprehensive insurance.

If enacted, HB 4806 would represent one of the most significant rollbacks of plaintiff rights in recent Texas history—erecting procedural roadblocks, suppressing valid claims, and limiting fair compensation for real injuries.

Ardalan Injury Law advocates for Texans fighting powerful insurance companies and corporate interests. If you have any questions or need help with a case, do not hesitate to contact us.