Texas Plaintiffs: How to Avoid Snap Removal to Federal Court
The scenario: you are representing a Texas plaintiff against a gaggle of defendants, some of which are based in Texas and others that are from out of state. You file suit in your local state court knowing that you are safe from removal. You send your citations to the process server. A week later, service of process on the in-state (or forum) defendants is taking a bit longer than expected and one of the out-of-state defendants has been successfully sued. You get back from lunch and see that your case has been removed to federal court. How can it be? After all, the parties in the case are not completely diverse so the federal court does not have subject matter jurisdiction.
Defendants are achieving this feat by using the plain language of the forum defendant rule. Under the forum defendant rule, a suit that is “otherwise removable solely on the basis of [diversity of citizenship] may not be removed if any of the parties in interest properly joined and served as defendants is a citizen of the State in which such action is brought.” Id. § 1441(b)(2). Several Circuit Courts of of Appeals, including the 5th Circuit have endorsed a new reading of 28 US Code § 1441(b)(2) whereby a served non-forum defendant can remove the entire case to federal court if no forum-defendants have been served. See Texas Brine Co. v. Am. Arbitration Assoc., 955 F. 3d 482 (5th Cir. 2020). Several other circuits have adopted the snap removal rule, and it seems like it is here to stay unless and until Congress acts.
Often, the decision to bring a lawsuit in state or federal court can be outcome-determinative; especially in Texas. Avoid snap removal by maybe naming only forum-defendants in your original petition and joining out of state parties in a later amended pleading? Or be sure to “properly join and serve” your forum-defendants prior to attempting service on any out of state defendants.
If you have any questions about civil procedure, personal injury or any other questions, please feel free to visit the Ardalan Law Firm website or contact us directly at ard@ardalanfirm.com.