Tesla Moves to Texas – Subject Matter Jurisdiction Consequences
Tesla announced that it is moving its headquarters from California to Texas. While this will undoubtedly be a big loss for California’s economy and boon to the local Texas economy, it also may help claimants against the carmaker keep their claims out of U.S. federal courts. As many of you other civil procedure nerds may remember from law school, one of the requirements for federal diversity subject matter jurisdiction is that the adverse parties be completely diverse from each other. A claim where any of the plaintiffs and defendants are residents in the same state does not fall under a federal court’s subject matter jurisdiction based on diversity.
In the past, a Texas resident suing Tesla in state court would likely see the claim removed to a local federal court. But not so going forward. Texas residents who sue Tesla, or any other car-maker with their HQ in Texas, now may be faced with the choice to sue in their Texas state courts or tempt their fate before their friendly local U.S. District Judge.
On the flipside, the California lemon-law plaintiffs’ firms that are allegedly running wild must now sue Tesla in their federal courts. This move probably comes as a relief to the good people at the American Tort Reform Association who regularly pine about the plight of tort defendants like carmakers in California.
Any opinions expressed here are only those of the author. If you have any questions about product liability or personal injury law in general, contact Ardalan Law Firm at ard@ardalanfirm.com