Free consultation · No fee unless you win · Hablamos Español 1211 W 6th St, Suite 600-122, Austin, TX · (512) 473-6449

‹ All Posts

TXSC: Amazon is not a “seller” under Texas defective products law

Product Liability & Recalls

TXSC: Amazon is not a "seller" under Texas defective products law

The Texas Supreme Court sided with Amazon in a nationwide battle over the online retail giant’s liability for selling dangerous third-party product. See Amazon, Inc. v. McMillan,  No. 20-0979 (Tex. 2021).  The Court was asked to certify a question from the 5th Circuit about whether a plaintiff could hold Amazon liable under Texas’ product liability scheme. McMillan v. Amazon. com, Inc., 983 F. 3d 194 (5th Circ. 2020). The statutory language in dispute;

(3)  “Seller” means a person who is engaged in the business of distributing or otherwise placing, for any commercial purpose, in the stream of commerce for use or consumption a product or any component part thereof. Tex. Prac. & Rem. Code Sec. 82.001(3).

The case involved a minor who was injured by a product sold through Amazon’s marketplace. The product in question was a knock-off remote control made in China. The third-party seller and manufacturer were located abroad and were otherwise outside the jurisdiction of U.S. courts. Amazon stored the defective product and sold it through its Amazon Prime program. In a narrow 5-4 majority opinion, the Court rejected the plaintiff’s arguments that Amazon fit under this broad definition of “seller” and instead focused on whether there was an exchange of title. This was the Court’s reasoning:

 “[T]he district court’s statement that “Texas law does not require an entity to transfer title or sell a product to be considered a seller” is not generally applicable. In cases where an ordinary sale occurs, a sale analysis—transfer of title for a price—is used to identify which person or entity qualifies as a seller of the product. […] Considering title to determine seller status is also consistent with the approach taken by other jurisdictions that follow the Restatement’s framework for strict products liability. Using this approach, many courts have concluded that Amazon is not a seller when it does not hold or relinquish title to the product. See, e.g., State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Amazon.com, Inc., 835 F. App’x 213, 216 (9th Cir. 2020) (holding that Amazon was not a “seller” under Arizona’s common-law Restatement-based multi-factor test, under which holding title is a factor); Erie Ins. Co. v. Amazon.com, Inc., 925 F.3d 135, 144 (4th Cir. 2019) (concluding that Amazon did not hold title and thus was not a “seller” under Maryland law, which is based on Restatement section 402A); Eberhart v. Amazon.com, Inc., 325 F. Supp. 3d 393, 397-98 (S.D.N.Y. 2018) (concluding that “regardless of what attributes are necessary to place an entity within the chain of distribution, the failure to take title to a product places that entity on the outside,” and such a requirement is reinforced by the Restatement (Third) of Torts: Products Liability); but see State Farm Fire & Cas. Co. v. Amazon.com Servs., Inc., 137 N.Y.S.3d 884, 889 (Sup. Ct. 2020) (disagreeing with Eberhart that title is dispositive under New York law).[14] In sum, we conclude that when a product-related injury arises from a transaction involving a sale, sellers are those who have relinquished title to the allegedly defective product at some point in the chain of distribution. The rule that a person need not transfer title to be held strictly liable is limited to non-sale commercial transactions.”

Going forward practitioners in the area of product liability law should tread carefully when weighing whether to sue Amazon, Etsy, Ebay, or any other marketplace where the products are sold by third-parties, in Texas. In these cases, often the only defendant who is within U.S. court’s jurisdiction is the online marketplace owner. The Court’s sudden shift to a “transfer of title” definition of “seller” will likely leave thousands of claimants without any path to recovery. On the flipside, this opinion comes as welcome to relief to Amazon who potentially faced a flood of litigation from dangerous products as outlined in this recent Wall Street Journal expose. Expect more accusations of forum-shopping as other jurisdictions take a different approach.

Dangerously manufactured electronics enter the U.S. market every day. Manufacturers of dangerous electronics that present a choking hazard to children market their defective products through retail giants like Amazon. If you are considering a claim against the manufacturer of a defective toy or defective electronic product in Texas, you must consult with a qualified Texas product liability lawyer.  

If you need assistance with a product liability matter or other personal injury case in Texas, please contact Ardalan Law Firm. We specialize in representing victims of dangerous products like dangerous electronic devices, dangerous toys, and other defective products. We are located in Austin, Texas. The author can be reached at (512) 473-6449 or ard@ardalanfirm.com.