Texas Law Now Shields Trucking Companies’ Worst Behavior
It is now much harder for Texans injured by trucking companies to recover damages at trial; a big win for the insurance industry. The Texas Legislature passed HB19, which in its original form was a seven headed hydra that was eventually watered down to its current form. The law complicates an already difficult area of trial practice (see Texas’s modified comparative fault statute and exemplary damages caps). The law’s main provisions can be summarized as such:
- Bifurcated trial: the law splits up commercial trucking trials into two phases. In the first phase, the jury will assess the truck driver’s liability and the amount of so-called compensatory damages to be paid. If a driver is found to be negligent in the first phase of the trial, it may be sufficient basis to proceed to the second phase of the trial. In the second phase, the jury will assess the employer’s liability and if any exemplary damages should be awarded.
- New Limits on Failure to Comply with Regulations Claims: In phase one, only certain specific violations that could have proximately caused the driver to be involved in a truck accident are admissible. In the second phase, a plaintiff can introduce evidence of failure to comply to support a claim for exemplary damages.
- New Limits on Employer Liability in Phase One: In phase one, if the trucking company stipulates that the driver was their employer, and was acting in the scope of his employment at the time of the wreck, there can be no negligent entrustment claim. Those claims and any others that may be predicated on the negligence of the driver have to wait for phase two.
- Admissibility of Property Damage Photos: Photos and videos of the scene don’t require an expert to authenticate and can be admitted as long as they comply with the Texas Rules of Evidence.
Commentary:
One of the stated reason for passing this law was to lower insurance premiums for trucking companies; but it very well may do the opposite. HB 19 needlessly complicates trucking cases by splitting the claims and damages into two phases of trial. It presents serious new trial risks for both plaintiffs and defense lawyers. For example, jurors already weary that defense lawyers are “hiding the ball” will have their suspicions confirmed when it’s revealed to them in phase two that the trucking company was actually the culprit all along. In cases where there are serious negligent entrustment claims, this process will simply increase the cost of litigation for both plaintiffs and the insurance companies. We have yet to see the new law play out in trial courts. Stay tuned for more developments, contact us, or browse the Ardalan Law Firm‘s trucking attorney page.