Free consultation · No fee unless you win · Hablamos Español 1211 W 6th St, Suite 600-122, Austin, TX · (512) 473-6449

‹ All Posts

I’ve been served with a Texas subpoena, am I in trouble?

Texas Law & Courts

I've been served with a Texas subpoena, am I in trouble?

Take a deep breath; you are not in trouble. You or your client has been served with a subpoena from an unrelated civil case that you may know nothing about. Fortunately, responding to a subpoena is routine practice for most litigators. A subpoena is a discovery request used by lawyers and courts to obtain documents or testimony from third parties. If you need help navigating the subpoena, take the following steps and make sure to consult with an attorney who has experience with Texas civil discovery procedures.

 Step 1: Get a copy of the subpoena request and read it!

First, ascertain whether the subpoena is related to a Texas state case or federal case. The rules are substantially similar with minor differences. For state court cases refer to Tex. R. Civ. P. 176, 192-193,199, 200, 205. In Federal cases, the rules are Fed. R. Civ. P. 26, 30-31, and 45. Then look to see what is being requested: a document subpoena typically asks for specific business records or other documents. A trial or deposition subpoena requests the presence of a witness at a trial, hearing or deposition. Sometimes a subpoena duces tecum requests both a witness’s attendance in addition to the production of documents. 

Step 2: Make sure the subpoena is valid and follows the minimum form requirements

A Texas subpoena must adhere to specific rules, see Tex. R. Civ. P. 176.1 (or Fed. Rule 45). If it does not conform with the rules, you can object or file a motion to quash based on a violation of any of the following:  

A  subpoena  issued  in  a  state  case  must  be  issued  in  the name  of  “The  State  of  Texas”  and: 

  (a) state  the  style  of  the  suit  and  its  cause  number; 

  (b) state  the  court  in  which  the  subpoena  is  pending; 

  (c) state  the  date  on  which  the  subpoena  is  issued; 

  (d) identify  the  person  to  whom  the  subpoena  is directed; 

  (e) state  the  time,  place,  and  nature  of  the  action required  by  the  person  to  whom  the  subpoena  is directed,  as  provided  in  TEX.  R.  CIV.  P.  176.2;

  (f) identify  the  party  at  whose  instance  the  subpoena is  issued,  and  the  party’s  attorney  of  record,  if  any;

  (g) include  the  text  of  Tex.  R. Civ.  P. 176.8(a); and

  (h) be  signed  by  the  person  issuing  the  subpoena.

Step 3: Pick up the phone and call the issuing attorney.

If the subpoena is from a litigating party, call the issuing attorney and go over the requests. Sometimes subpoenas are worded very broadly and the party is only really seeking very specific information. Find out what information or documents need to be produced to satisfy the subpoena. If you or your client does not want to produce the documents or witness(es) requested, you can try and reach a compromise with counsel with civility and in line with the Texas Lawyer’s Creed. You can narrow the scope of a subpoena but make sure to get any agreement in writing from the issuing attorney. 

Step 4: Prepare a motion, objections, and/or response.

Meet with your client and decide what, if anything will be produced. If there are objections that need to be made, you should make them before the deadline for compliance and be prepared to present an argument to the court about why certain materials should be exempted from the subpoena. The objections that can be made with regard to a subpoena request are substantially similar to those made in response to a request for production. Practically, a judge will weigh whether the subpoena places an undue burden on the third party in relation to the needs of the case. Some of the most common substantive objections made to a subpoena are:

• Overly broad.

• Undue burden or expense.

• Harassing, annoying, or embarrassing.

• Irrelevant to claim or defense.

• Unreasonably duplicative or cumulative.

• Seeks disclosure of privileged information.

• Seeks confidential and proprietary information.

• Seeks discovery in a form not permitted by the rules or agreed by stipulation.

• Invasion of personal, constitutional or property rights.

• Seeks information that the issuing party has had ample opportunity to discover on its own or that is obtainable from some other source that is more convenient.

Conclusion

If the subpoena is a source of contention for you and your client, consider calling a civil litigator that regularly issues and responds to document subpoenas. Make sure to perform a thorough review of the responsive documents for relevance, privilege, and/or confidentiality. I hope this post is informative. Feel free to visit www.ardalanfirm.com, reach out at (512) 473-6449 or ard@ardalanfirm.com if you have any questions or comments.